We started with an order of "Alligator Bites". I had never tried alligator and I figured when in Rome... These were bites of gator tail, dusted in seasoned flour and then flash fried:
I hate to sound completely stereotypical and generic, but alligator really does taste a lot like chicken! These were delicious. Slightly chewy, which apparently alligator always is, but still pretty tender. They had a nice, fresh, and light taste to them. And call me a redneck, but just about anything is going to be tasty if you fry it. I loved these, but am interested in trying alligator that hasn't been covered in flour and fried.
For dinner, I ordered "The Steamer Bucket". It's exactly like it sounds, a bucket filled to the brim with Crab legs, shrimp, mussels, and clams with a side of drawn butter. (Cue choir of angels singing "Ahhh!")
If this does not look like a heavenly bucket of deliciousness, then you are a fool on a fools journey. This was amazing. Some of the best, freshest tasting seafood I've ever had. Crabby Bill's is doing something very right. The crab legs were so tender and succulent, the shrimp were big and seasoned perfectly, the mussels and clams were soft and not overcooked at all. My Mom and I split this bucket and, while we were very full by the time we reached the bottom, wanted 5 more. This is a meal you work for but worth every crack, peel and pull. There is something very communal and fun about eating this food with friends and family; everyone sitting around cracking crab legs and peeling shrimp, laughing and talking, and then enjoying their delicious end result together with messy hands and butter all over your face. We had a blast.